Here’s what usually happens.
A manager submits a job specification to HR and it is written into an ad and/or put out to recruiters, retained or contingency, who run around trying to fill the job.
Managers then interview with dumb questions that do little to evaluate or truly assess. They re-evaluate the spec in their mind but never communicate changes to the people, both internal and external, who are beating the bushes to support them.
All the while, they are asking questions that come from some industrial psychology playbook but ultimately involves looking someone in the eye and guessing whether they can do the job and fit into the organization.
I could go into this diatribe with examples galore from what I have heard from managers who complain about the process instituted about HR and from HR professionals who complain about interview incompetence by hiring managers.
Does this all make a lot of sense to you? Continuing with systems like this sure doesn’t make a lot of sense to me. The solution doesn’t involve throwing out the system except those that are required for government compliance.
There is a simple to implement solution that will allow your managers to hire with greater certainty and hire people with more drive and motivation.
Contract-to-hire or Temp-to-perm.
According to a recent survey, there are now six job applicants for every available job. In two years the tide will probably turn and you may lose your leverage with unemployed labor.
By offering them a contract-to-hire or temp-to-perm offer (I differentiate a contract-to-hire as being a skilled professional; a temp-to-perm is someone who might be an administrative role) you will have a very motivated worker who will have to prove themselves prior to being hired and your firm will be protected against a bad hire.
If the person doesn’t perform, let them go! A client told me about a mistake they hired recently who just couldn’t deliver what they said they could. The employer is now are on the hook for unemployment insurance and have to start from scratch interviewing.
With a contract to hire, they could have continued to interview as a fallback, just in case.
Plus you can put them on the payroll with one of your existing consulting vendors and let them make a few dollars free. They’ll love you for it. Just make sure there is no conversion fee when you switch them to staff!
© 2009 all rights reserved.